Peabody Energy: Delays With Centurion, But The Valuation Is Extremely Compelling
November 16, 2026 - Peabody Energy (BTU) is the largest coal mining company in the United States. With that said, slightly more than half of its earnings typically come from the mines in Australia and that figure will climb with the flagship mine, Centurion, now ramping up production.
The company has four segments; Seaborne Thermal, Seaborne Metallurgical, Other U.S. Thermal, and Powder River Basin. The latter two segments have had more of an impact on earnings and cash flow over the last couple of years, when coal prices have been weaker. However, during periods of stronger coal prices, the two seaborne segments, with most of production in Australia, account for most of the earnings.
Figure 1 - source: Peabody Energy Quarterly Reports
The stock price performance of Peabody Energy has been very poor this year, down 41% with dividends included. Both thermal coal and coking coal prices have increased this year, making the recent underperformance very frustrating. Few coal miners have excelled this year, but Peabody has been among the worst performers.
The delay with the ramp up of the flagship Centurion mine in Australia is likely one of the main reasons for why Peabody has underperformed. However, this is just a delay getting through a fault zone and there are no balance sheet or liquidity concerns.
Another potential reason for the underperformance is the exposure to the domestic U.S. coal market, which is probably not going to thrive with the Democratic party controlling the House and the Senate going forward. With that said, Peabody sells most of its domestic coal on longer-term contracts. I am also not all that concerned we will see aggressive moves against the coal industry in the short term to push energy prices higher in an inflationary environment.
It is also worth pointing out that I primarily invest in Peabody for the two seaborne segments, with most of the production coming from Australia, even if the two lower margin U.S. segments typically provide a welcomed boost to earnings.
Figure 2 - Source: Koyfin
Q3 2026 Results
Peabody reported an adjusted EBITDA of $97.5M in the most recent quarter, up from the prior quarter. All four segments had a positive contribution to adjusted EBITDA while the Seaborne Thermal segment was the main contributor.
Figure 3 - source: Peabody Energy Quarterly Reports
The Seaborne Thermal segment sold 3.1 million tons of coal in the most recent quarter. The sales price increased slightly compared to the prior quarter to $77.6/t and costs decreased slightly to $56.6/t, which in turn led to an improved EBITDA margin of $21.1/t. The adjusted EBITDA was $65.5M in the segment during Q3 2026.
Figure 4 - source: Peabody Energy Quarterly Reports
The Seaborne Metallurgical segment sold 2.2 million tons of coal in the most recent quarter, roughly in line with guidance for the quarter. The EBITDA margin was just marginally positive at $2/t and we are still waiting for Centurion to fully ramp up, which is expected to take place in 2027.
Centurion shipped 0.58 million tons in Q3 2026 but experienced some more disruptions in October as the company is still working through a fault zone, so the Q4 guidance has been lowered some. There are more fault zones in the mine plan down the line, but the company should soon be through the current one, with easier longwall mining the next couple of years, and have better learned how to deal with these more challenging zones in the future. The recent delays are far from ideal, but should be viewed as short-term disruptions according to management.
Figure 5 - source: Peabody Energy Quarterly Reports
The Other U.S. Thermal and Powder River Basin segments generated $26M and $15M in adjusted EBITDA in Q3 2026, which does provide a healthy boost to the consolidated result.
Figure 6 - source: Peabody Energy Quarterly Reports
Figure 7 - source: Peabody Energy Quarterly Reports
The cash position was $434M at the end of Q3 2026 for Peabody and the debt was $297M, with most of the debt in convertibles that pay an interest rate of 0.5% and matures in 2031. The conversion price is now close to $50.61 per share following a capped call transaction as well. There are effectively no balance sheet or liquidity concerns for Peabody.
Peabody pays a quarterly dividend of $0.075, which equates to a dividend yield of 1.7%. Most of the cash flow will however go towards buybacks going forward, where the company has been committed to returning a substantial amount of cash flow to its shareholders. My expectation is that we will see the share count decrease materially over the coming years, similar to what we saw in the 2023-2024 period. The investments in Centurion and weaker coal prices are the reasons the share count has been roughly flat over the last couple of years.
Figure 8 - Source: Koyfin
Conclusion
Peabody had yet another lackluster quarter due to a slow ramp up of Centurion, softer coal prices, and higher costs from inflation.
2026 will be a softer year for Peabody due to weaker coal prices and the slow ramp up of Centurion. The EBITDA consensus estimate for the next couple of years is around $700M, which feels like a conservative estimate in my view, and that translates to an EV to EBITDA of 2.7-2.9. This is an extremely compelling valuation multiple, and I would note that Peabody has the potential to generate well above $1B in EBITDA during peak years compared to the current enterprise value of $2B.
This is the most compelling coal mining company around at current prices, which is why I have been growing my holdings in Peabody aggressively following the recent sell-off.
There is still some execution risk remaining with Centurion and there is always political risk for coal mining companies. However, coal prices are very low compared to natural gas prices and the coal mining companies are cheap on top of that. So, Peabody and other coal miners offer good risk rewards here. Following the depressed share price of Peabody, I rate the stock as a strong buy.
It is difficult to know how long it will take for Peabody and coal miners to recover from the current weak sentiment. However, at the current $17 share price, I see very limited downside over a 2–3-year period.