Signature Sponsor
Coal Firms Scheming to Gut Retiree Healthcare Coverage, UMWA and Miners Say

 


November 18, 2026 - Coal companies owned by West Virginia Senator Jim Justice have been accused of devising a scheme to strip mine worker retirees and their dependents of healthcare and prescription drug insurance coverage the companies are contractually obligated to provide.

That’s the main allegation registered in a Monday court filing from retired miners and the United Mine Workers of America, in which the union’s president contends that in recent weeks, Justice’s coal business network has sought to unilaterally replace a negotiated healthcare plan with a “reimbursement scheme” that would significantly increase retirees’ cost burdens and leave those under age 65 without any coverage at all. 

Such a move would constitute the latest in a long string of failures to provide uninterrupted coverage in violation of a federal court order forbidding such stoppages.

The UMWA and four retired miners’ filing comes in a 7-year-old federal court case in which those plaintiffs say five Justice coal companies have again violated a 2021 court order to provide them and other retirees uninterrupted healthcare and prescription drug coverage.

The union and miners contend that the Justice coal firms — Justice Energy Company, Inc., Keystone Service Industries, Inc., Bluestone Coal Corp., Double-Bonus Coal Company and Southern Coal Corp., have again failed to pay insurance premiums, leaving beneficiaries without needed prescription medications and required beneficiaries to pay for medications themselves and to then wait for reimbursement from the companies.

In their filing, the plaintiff miners and UMWA say that in anticipation of an Oct. 19 oral argument hearing, the companies “undertook a scheme” to sign retirees and other beneficiaries up to a unilaterally imposed Medicare Advantage program. Medicare Advantage programs are federally regulated plans from a private company that offer an alternative to the federal government’s traditional Medicare program.

But the UMWA and miners say the Justice-pushed Medicare Advantage plan is an “inferior” plan to an already negotiated employer plan, not offering the same level of benefits.

The miners and union say the companies’ imposition of the Medicare Advantage plan doesn’t cover all retirees or beneficiaries and leaves beneficiaries under 65 without coverage “in direct conflict with” a June 2021 federal court order requiring the companies to maintain a contractually agreed-upon employer plan.

The plaintiffs report that at the Oct. 19 hearing, counsel for the Justice coal firms admitted that in April, when the plaintiffs filed a motion asking the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia to hold the firms in contempt for their noncompliance with the 2021 order, the coverage that existed was “inconsistent, inefficient and not sustainable” because of the companies’ “limited operations and limited resources to continue to find the self-funded plan that was in place.”

The UMWA and miners have asked the court to:

  • Enter an order finding the companies in contempt for failure to comply with the order

  • Award damages covering out-of-pocket expenses incurred by the retirees and their dependents over the time during which their prescription drug coverage was terminated

  • Direct the companies to pay the plaintiffs’ attorney fees stemming from the contempt proceeding

  • Issue whatever sanctions the court deems appropriate to “coerce obedience” and compensate the plaintiffs for their reported losses

In the filing, the miners and union say retirees have had to endure payment demands from impacted healthcare providers and “have suffered from the insecurity and anxiety” caused by what they say are the companies’ “knowing and willful failure to comply with the” 2021 order in the case filed in 2019 — two years into Justice’s eight-year tenure as governor.

UMWA spokesperson Erin Bates previously told the Gazette-Mail that about 300 members have been affected.

Justice pledged that he would put his children in charge of his family’s business operations upon becoming West Virginia’s governor in 2017. Justice has suggested in interviews and court proceedings after he became governor that he remains familiar with his coal companies’ operations.

The Justice coal companies hadn’t lodged a filing in response to the plaintiffs’ Monday motion as of Tuesday afternoon.

UMWA: Justice firms 'utterly failed' to fund backstop   

The union and miners note in their latest filing that in September 2022, the union, Justice Energy and Bluestone Resources entered into a memorandum of understanding requiring the companies to fund and maintain an escrow account to serve as a backstop when the firms otherwise failed to pay for health and prescription benefits. The agreement mandated a $175,000 escrow account deposit from the companies to support the payment of healthcare and prescription drug coverage benefits for active and laid-off employees and for retirees per the parties’ 2016 collective bargaining agreement.

But the companies have “utterly failed to fund the escrow account” since first doing so in January 2023, the plaintiffs said in their latest filing. The plaintiffs recalled February 2026 testimony from UMWA associate general counsel Hill Pickens indicating the escrow account was funded to levels required under the 2022 memorandum of understanding for just six days – from Jan. 27, 2023, to Feb. 2, 2023, and that since Feb. 2, 2024, the escrow account has had a balance of under $100.

The UMWA also recalled that it has sought an appointment via the court of a special master to:

  • Administer an escrow account outside of the defendants’ possession and therefore not subject to creditor liens, to be funded by the defendants at the $175,000 level established in the memorandum of understanding

  • Review, approve or deny, and process requests to transfer funds from the escrow account to the defendants’ third-party administrator(s) to ensure uninterrupted provision of health and prescription drug benefits

  • To monitor escrow funding levels and alert the court and the plaintiffs when the escrow is not replenished within the time frames established by the memorandum of understanding

  • Provide monthly or periodic reports to the court and the plaintiffs regarding the defendants’ level of compliance or noncompliance

  • Recommend, in the event of noncompliance, contempt sanctions to the court

'Such a result could have devastating consequences'

The plaintiffs’ filing Monday included testimony from UMWA International President Brian Sanson reporting that what he called Bluestone’s “health care reimbursement scheme” to replace the negotiated employer plan requires each beneficiary to pay their insurance premiums, copayments, deductibles and other out-of-pocket costs.

The companies have proposed to issue checks to beneficiaries to cover those outlays for retirees 65 and older, with those under 65 — including those that are disabled — left without coverage, Sanson testified.

Sanson said that, after reviewing the Justice companies’ communications to employer plan beneficiaries describing their efforts to terminate the 2016 collective bargaining agreement-produced plan and “replace it with an inferior substitute” as well as reviewing plan benefit summaries they intend to make available for retirees over 65, he identified “harms” that include:

  • The companies seeking to impose a Medicare voucher program on its retirees through which they would pay a fixed amount per month to each Medicare-eligible retiree, shifting the burden of providing a plan of benefits from Justice to the retirees

  • The amounts provided won’t be adequate to replicate the benefits the retirees worked to earn under the 2016 collective bargaining agreement-produced plan, with the replacement voucher plan also providing no guarantee of future “lifetime” benefits

  • The companies’ “reimbursement scheme” would impose a significant administrative burden on retirees, notably since their UMWA retirees have never had to navigate the Medicare marketplace, depending on the UWMA to negotiate a plan of benefits and Bluestone to administer those benefits

  • Since the companies are terminating their employer plans for Medicare-eligible retirees and surviving spouses, those beneficiaries would have to enroll in supplemental Medicare and prescription drug plans to have coverage beyond traditional Medicare, with such plans likely consuming all the company-contemplated health reimbursement and leaving retirees to pay “significant sums out of their pockets”

  • Retirees who can’t afford out-of-pocket costs are likely to forgo enrollment in supplemental plans or treatment once their monthly reimbursement amounts are exhausted

“Such a result could have devastating consequences for the health and well-being of the retirees,” Sanson’s declaration, dated Monday, states.