Signature Sponsor
West Virginia Coal Association Raises Rail Service Concerns Over Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern Merger

 


November 19, 2026 - The West Virginia Coal Association is asking federal regulators to take a close look at how the proposed Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger would affect coal shipments from the Mountain State, where some mines have no practical alternative to Norfolk Southern for getting coal to steel mills, power plants and export terminals.


In comments filed Nov. 18 with the Surface Transportation Board, association Executive Vice President Jason D. Bostic said Norfolk Southern handled about 45% of the West Virginia coal that moved by rail in 2024. The association took no formal position on the merger. It asked the board to consider what it takes to keep Appalachian coal moving as it reviews the deal.


Norfolk Southern and CSX are West Virginia’s only Class I railroads, according to the association. The state’s 11 regional and short-line railroads connect to one or both. The association said 58 mines and 38 preparation plants accounted for about 21 million tons moving on Norfolk Southern in 2024, including coal that reached its network through regional railroads. In six of the state’s 22 coal-producing counties, the association said, Norfolk Southern is the only available outlet for mined coal.


The terrain limits the options. Many mines sit far from navigable rivers, and trucks typically haul coal only as far as a preparation plant or rail loadout. In the association’s example, diverting a typical coal train’s load to another rail or river loading site would take more than 250 truckloads traveling more than 100 miles. The group estimates that coal moved by Norfolk Southern in 2024 generated about $109 million in severance taxes, with more than $12 million returned to county and local governments where the coal was mined, processed and loaded.

 

Why Appalachian Coal Moves Differently

 

Much of Union Pacific’s coal business consists of full trains carrying thermal coal from a single mine to a power plant or other customer on a regular schedule. West Virginia coal can take a more complicated trip. At smaller Norfolk Southern loadouts, local crews drop off empty cars and return for loaded ones. Where steep terrain leaves little room for a loop track, crews may have to split a train into groups of cars for loading and put it back together afterward.


Steelmakers need blends of metallurgical coal that meet the specifications of their coke ovens and furnaces. A shipment may contain coal from several mines, each supplying a different grade. Export terminals may hold loaded cars until every grade needed for a vessel arrives. The association estimates that railroads carried 93% of West Virginia’s export metallurgical coal to loading facilities. It said Norfolk Southern carried 53% of the state’s coal shipments to domestic coke makers and steel producers and hauled nearly 10 million tons of West Virginia metallurgical coal to deepwater export facilities.


One of those outlets is Norfolk Southern’s Lamberts Point terminal in Norfolk, Virginia. The railroad lists its annual capacity at 48 million tons and says most of the terminal’s business is metallurgical coal exports. Crews there can blend coal as it is transferred from railcars to ships.


The association also pointed to 3.6 million tons of West Virginia thermal coal that Norfolk Southern carried to Eastern power plants in 2024. Those plants represent roughly 24,000 megawatts of generating capacity, according to the filing. The association said nearly all of them receive coal only by rail and are served exclusively by Norfolk Southern. Some require Appalachian coal with specific heating, sulfur or other characteristics suited to their boilers and pollution controls. Delayed trains can leave those plants drawing down stockpiles with few options for replacement fuel.

 

What the Railroads Say

 

Union Pacific announced the cash-and-stock deal in July 2025, putting Norfolk Southern’s enterprise value at $85 billion. The companies say the combined railroad would span more than 50,000 route miles across 43 states and speed up shipments by eliminating handoffs between carriers. In supplemental filings, they expanded a program designed to protect pricing at certain interchange points to include eligible bulk unit-train traffic.


The American Iron and Steel Institute urged the board to reject the merger in a separate Nov. 18 filing, arguing that consolidation would further limit shipping choices for steelmakers. Illinois coal producer Foresight Energy asked the board to make approval contingent on BNSF getting track access to two mines now served by both Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern. On Nov. 19, the two applicants said they had filed a response to Canadian Pacific Kansas City’s request to end the merger review and urged the board to complete its evaluation.


The merger remains under review in Surface Transportation Board Docket FD 36873. Any preliminary comments from the Justice and Transportation departments are due Dec. 3. Responses to opening comments and requests for conditions are due Feb. 16, 2027, and final briefs are due May 28. The board plans to hold a public hearing and has yet to set a date.