Signature Sponsor
Ohio Coal Plant Owner Could Sidestep 2028 Shutdown Deal Under Proposed Bill

 

 

November 20, 2026 - Under a draft bill obtained by Canary Media, settlement agreements resolving disputes before state courts or regulators could no longer force coal plants to close. The proposal would apply to both existing and future agreements between private parties and plant owners. Republican lawmakers were seeking passage of the measure ahead of the inauguration of Amy Acton, the state's Democratic governor-elect.


Should the proposal become law, Buckeye Power could continue operating its coal unit at the Cardinal power plant if requested or directed to do so by various individuals or agencies. It would also allow the owner to set aside the shutdown requirements contained in any settlement agreements. 


The shutdown was one of several measures American Electric Power's Ohio utility agreed to in a 2015 regulatory settlement with the Sierra Club, according to Canary Media. The utility owned part of Cardinal at the time. Buckeye Power took over AEP's obligations for Cardinal following a sale in 2022.


The proposal also followed years of legislative barriers imposed upon renewable energy. Renewable energy projects could reduce electricity costs and the heat-trapping pollution driving rising global temperatures, but legislators have put obstacles in the path of such projects. 

 

Buckeye Power told Canary Media that it "supports the draft legislation and intends to file testimony in its favor after it is introduced."


Buckeye Power cited electricity costs and reliability for Ohio consumers as reasons for its support. It described the proposal as "a balanced and narrowly tailored solution that helps keep electricity reliable and affordable for Ohio consumers by allowing critical generation resources to remain available until the reliability crisis has passed."


Ohio's prohibition against retroactive laws was central to the Sierra Club's constitutional concerns about the measure. Neil Waggoner, the Midwest coordinator of the environmental group's Beyond Coal campaign, cited that prohibition in questioning the proposal's reach, according to Canary Media.


For Waggoner, the concern went beyond Cardinal's shutdown date to whether settlement commitments would remain enforceable more broadly. 


"My first thought was, 'Why is there a piece of legislation trying to go against the Ohio Constitution?'" Waggoner told Canary Media. "This breaks not just any contract moving forward but also breaks any previous contract."